Why Is Self-Employment Tax So High?

  • John A. Osborne
  • May 18, 2023
Small Business Insurance Minnesota

Self-employment tax is often a topic of discussion among entrepreneurs and freelancers. Many wonder why it is so high and how it affects their business. To understand why self-employment tax is high, it is important to explore the various factors that contribute to it. In this article, we will delve into the reasons behind the high self-employment tax and what it means for self-employed individuals.

Self-employment tax is the tax that individuals who work for themselves pay on their income. It includes both the employer and employee portions of Social Security and Medicare taxes. The current self-employment tax rate is 15.3%, and it is calculated on net earnings from self-employment. This tax is in addition to income tax, which can lead to a high tax burden for self-employed individuals. So why is self-employment tax so high? Let’s find out.

Lack of Employer Contributions

One reason why self-employment tax is high is that self-employed individuals are responsible for paying both the employer and employee portions of Social Security and Medicare taxes. When someone is employed by a company, the employer pays a portion of these taxes on their behalf. However, self-employed individuals do not have this luxury, and they must pay the entire amount themselves.

This lack of employer contributions can result in a higher tax burden for self-employed individuals than for those who are employed by a company. The employer portion of Social Security and Medicare taxes is currently 7.65%, which can add up to a significant amount of money for those who are self-employed.

Higher Income Thresholds

Another reason why self-employment tax is high is that the income thresholds for Social Security and Medicare taxes are higher for self-employed individuals than for those who are employed by a company. For 2021, the Social Security tax applies to earnings up to $142,800, while the Medicare tax applies to all earnings. However, self-employed individuals must pay both taxes on all of their net earnings, regardless of the amount.

This means that self-employed individuals who earn more than $142,800 are responsible for paying the full 15.3% self-employment tax on their income, whereas those who are employed by a company only pay the employer portion on income above this threshold. This can result in a higher tax burden for self-employed individuals with high net earnings.

No Deductions for Employer Contributions

Self-employed individuals also cannot deduct the employer portion of their Social Security and Medicare taxes on their tax returns. This means that they are unable to offset their tax liability with deductions for employer contributions, which can further increase their tax burden. In contrast, those who are employed by a company can deduct the employer portion of these taxes on their tax returns, which can lower their tax liability.

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, self-employment tax is high due to a variety of factors, including the lack of employer contributions, higher income thresholds, and the inability to deduct employer contributions. While self-employment can offer many benefits, it is important for self-employed individuals to be aware of the tax implications and plan accordingly. By understanding the reasons behind the high self-employment tax, entrepreneurs and freelancers can make informed decisions about their business and finances.